Regulation Professors
Regulation prof at public college suspended for Charlie Kirk feedback; does that violate First Modification?
September 18, 2025, 12:44 pm CDT
Charlie Kirk at Utah Valley College, the place he was shot and killed on Sept. 10. (Photograph by Trent Nelson/The Salt Lake Tribune/Getty Photos)
On-line feedback concerning the dying of political activist Charlie Kirk have led to the suspension of an assistant scientific training professor on the College of Arkansas Little Rock William H. Bowen College of Regulation.
Felicia Department, who directs and teaches within the regulation college’s Low Revenue Taxpayer Clinic, was suspended with pay and can be investigated.
Department wrote on Fb that she “won’t pull again from celebrating that an evil man died.” She additionally posted a meme displaying Ku Klux Klan members at a cross burning with a caption studying “Individuals mourning Charlie Kirk.”
Christina Drale, chancellor for the College of Arkansas at Little Rock, stated in an announcement that she helps the correct to freedom of expression however “I oppose such violent rhetoric within the strongest of phrases. As educators we should always maintain ourselves to the next normal of conduct that values civil discourse, speaks clearly concerning the risks of political violence, and that prioritizes a rigorous, fair-minded studying atmosphere. The postings I learn this morning don’t mirror this normal.”
Publications with protection embody Reuters, KATV, the Faculty Repair and KUAR.
Department started working on the regulation college in July. She wrote a number of Fb posts. One in all them learn, partly:
“It by no means fails. Individuals have come out caping for the satan that walked amongst us.
“Information flash Christians. The evil one isn’t one singular being. I’m going to wish ya’ll to review a bit extra.
“So no. I can’t pull again from celebrating that an evil man died by the strategy he selected to embrace.
“Don’t inform individuals who have been focused by somebody like him how you can really feel, how to not publish, how to not have a good time that he can not inflict his model of evil. ….
“You’re so fast to chastise, pondering we’re merely celebrating a dying. We. Are. Not. As I posted yesterday—evil begets evil. He’s not in a position to beget evil. That’s trigger celebre.”
Department went on to confer with Kirk’s earlier statements defending gun rights. Kirk has has stated he thinks the Second Modification proper is value the price of, sadly, some gun deaths yearly.
Arkansas Gov. Sarah Huckabee and Arkansas Lawyer Common Tim Griffin have each referred to as for Department to be fired.
“The First Modification protects your proper to say what you need,” Griffin stated in a press launch. “It doesn’t, nonetheless, assure you the job you need, no matter what you say. The regulation college ought to terminate her instantly.”
Free speech consultants have a distinct take.
“As a public college, the College of Arkansas is sure by the First Modification, which protects speech some could discover deeply unpopular or offensive,” says Zach Greenberg, school authorized protection/pupil affiliation counsel on the Basis for Particular person Rights and Expression, in an announcement emailed to the ABA Journal.
“School at public universities can’t be punished for merely expressing private views outdoors of labor, particularly on issues of public concern. We’re actively investigating this case and urge the college to uphold its constitutional obligations.
“There is no such thing as a ‘hate speech’ exception to the First Modification and there can’t be. The Supreme Court docket has rejected the thought again and again as a result of ‘hate speech’ is inherently subjective. Any try and outline it dangers giving the federal government energy to silence views it dislikes.”
Yale Regulation College professor Keith E. Whittington, writing on the Chronicle of Increased Schooling, additionally says public schools are constrained by the First Modification in how they will reply to calls for to punish workers for hateful and incendiary speech.
“It’s value clarifying that in the USA, constitutional protections for speech are expansive, a reality not all the time mirrored within the official statements from schools,” Whittington writes. His article referred to a number of firings and different disciplinary measures taken in opposition to faculty professors earlier than the controversy over Department’s statements surfaced.
Mere advocacy for violence is usually protected against felony prosecution by courts though incitement to imminent lawless actions and true threats will not be, he says.
Turning to the applying of the First Modification to authorities workers, Whittington says professors and directors at public schools “get pleasure from some important constitutional protections in opposition to disciplinary motion by their authorities employer for his or her expressive exercise.”
Professors at public universities usually have better First Modification safety than different authorities workers as a result of tutorial freedom has been acknowledged as a particular concern of the First Modification, he says. The protections are better when professors communicate of their private capability than when chatting with college students within the classroom.
“Given the particular nature of a professor’s duties to freely focus on controversial concepts, their distasteful and inflammatory speech is constitutionally tolerated. Professors who publicly celebrated Charlie Kirk’s dying ought to usually be immune from self-discipline,” he concludes.
Whittington nonetheless notes that universities are beneath extraordinary public stress and public confidence in them is “in a free fall.” If professors are seen as contributing to intolerance, the balancing carried out by courts requested to guard their freedom might change, he warns.
A Journal request for remark despatched to Department’s regulation college electronic mail deal with was returned as undeliverable. She didn’t instantly reply to a request for remark left on her regulation college voicemail.
Write a letter to the editor, share a narrative tip or replace, or report an error.
