Public figures usually discover their private lives beneath intense scrutiny, however what occurs when jokes amongst friends cross a line? In 2009, throughout an episode of Koffee with Karan, actors Deepika Padukone and Sonam Kapoor made remarks about their frequent hyperlink, Ranbir Kapoor.
Whereas Deepika jokingly instructed that Ranbir ought to endorse condoms, Sonam forged doubt on his credibility as a boyfriend. “I don’t assume he generally is a good boyfriend,” she mentioned, alluding to his alleged lack of seriousness in relationships.
The remarks didn’t go down effectively with Ranbir’s father, actor Rishi Kapoor, who hit again publicly. “What can I say about this? Everybody right here is like household. These two women are like my youngsters. I personally don’t need to leap into the battle of my son and his buddies. However these items mentioned by Deepika and Sonam present their class. I simply need to say that cease saying this on a regular basis and behave with maturity,” he had mentioned. He additional added, “Each of you’re within the present since you are your fathers’ daughters, not due to your work. I might advise them to cease speaking about their colleagues and insulting them.”
Story continues under this advert
Regardless that Deepika clarified later that it was mentioned in jest, stating, “We’re all buddies and if Ranbir doesn’t have an issue with it, I don’t see why anybody else ought to,” the incident left behind questions round how public conversations form reputations and the burden of a ‘joke’.
So, when ought to one draw the road between humour and disrespect when speaking a few former buddy or companion?
Gurleen Baruah, an existential analyst, tells indianexpress.com, “There’s no one-size-fits-all reply. It actually relies on the people concerned, the character of the previous relationship, and the intention behind the phrases. Humour is commonly used to manage, deflect, and even course of unresolved emotions, however when it entails another person—particularly a former companion—context and consent matter. What’s gentle for one particular person is likely to be deeply reducing for an additional. A joke made publicly, with out the opposite’s presence or consent, carries a special weight. From a psychological lens, the road is crossed when humour turns into a masks for judgment, bitterness, or public shaming. It’s much less about political correctness and extra about emotional duty.”
How can remarks made in jest affect the particular person’s fame and feelings?
Baruah mentions that jokes are sophisticated. They are often gentle, enjoyable, and even bonding, however after they contact on somebody’s private life, particularly in public, they’ll additionally sting. “Even when it’s ‘simply banter,’ the affect can last more than the snort. Some individuals snort it off; others carry it for years. Particularly when it performs into gossip or reinforces an present narrative, a joke can blur into commentary.” And whereas humour can soften issues, it doesn’t all the time erase the emotional residue.
So sure, jokes are allowed, however timing, tone, and context matter. A playful jab amongst buddies is one factor. A punchline on a nationwide platform? That may land very otherwise.
Do apologies or clarifications genuinely undo the injury?
Whether or not an apology repairs the injury relies on a number of issues—how real it feels, the timing, and the intent behind it. Individuals don’t all the time keep in mind the “sorry” as a lot as they keep in mind the sting. That mentioned, not all affect is everlasting. What issues is how the one that’s been affected is sensible of it—do they internalise it, or can they create a boundary between what was mentioned and who they know themselves to be?
Story continues under this advert
“Transferring ahead would possibly imply having direct conversations, setting limits, and even reshaping public notion over time. In some circumstances, it additionally relies on how the connection between the individuals concerned evolves. Humour, particularly in public areas, is difficult—one particular person’s joke will be one other’s bruise. However real restore is feasible when it’s paired with accountability and care,” explains Baruah.
